July 30, 2024

Written by

Sarah Kyle

5 Reasons You’re Not Getting a 2nd Date

Wondering why second dates are elusive? Explore the top 5 reasons you might not be getting one and learn how to improve your dating game!

You’re making the apps your part-time job, reaching out to potential matches and responding to folks who reach out to you. Sometimes you strike gold and land a date with someone who seems promising. Things go well, you allow yourself to get excited about the possibility of the next date, and then it never happens. After going through this experience more than once, you start to wonder why those 2nd dates aren’t materializing.

No worries, Get Dateable is here to help you figure this out! We’ve talked to lots of people about what seals their decision to not ask for a 2nd date, and here are the top 5 things they told us:

  1. Inauthenticity: The biggest turn-off daters report is going out with someone who is trying too hard. This can be evident in how you dress, how you groom yourself, how much cosmetic work you’ve had done, and most importantly in how you behave. Of course you want to wear something you feel great in; just make sure it’s something that feels like you. Stay present and tune in to the conversation so you can really respond in a way that feels true and authentic, rather than coming up with topics or answers you think the other person wants to hear. We’ve said this a thousand times before, and we will continue to tell you, who you are is good enough. Be the best you possible.
  2. Self-centeredness: Another reason our clients don’t go out with someone a 2nd time is because their date came across as self-centered. This can show up in the form of talking about yourself the whole time, not asking questions of the other person, or not showing an interest in them or what they want. Make sure you’re finding a good balance between being interested and interesting, showing curiosity about your date and also bringing engaging topics to the conversation.
  3. No goodness of fit: Sometimes your date is a great person but they’re just not the person for you. There is nothing wrong with a square peg or a round hole, the two just don’t fit together well. You may be physically active while your date prefers watching movies on the couch. In this case neither of you needs to change, you just need to find a more compatible partner. Don’t interpret this as a reflection of yourself.
  4. Unrealistic expectations: One of the factors that thwarts the desire for a 2nd date is not setting appropriate requests or demands with someone you barely know. Examples of this include expecting frequent texts or calls, anticipating they will pay for your expenses on dates, trying to influence what they do or don’t post on social media, or expectations of sexual intimacy. You may have projected traits onto them based on what you want to believe. In general, work on keeping expectations to a minimum and just observe how the person behaves. 
  5. Factors that have nothing to do with you: When you’ve just met someone you don’t really know much about what’s going on in their life. An old flame may have resurfaced the day after your first date and made an offer they couldn’t refuse. They may have been uber-attracted to you and realized they weren’t emotionally ready for that. They may have found out you have a mutual connection that could tell you damaging information about them. There are a whole host of reasons they don’t ask for a 2nd date that have absolutely nothing to do with you. Practice not taking this personally.

At Get Dateable we can help you mitigate all these things so you’ll get more 2nd dates. Membership in our exclusive community will have you passing these milestones with flying colors. Join us today.

Want to be part of our exclusive community?

You're ready to up-level your dating experience and surround yourself with an amazing group of Austin singles. Stop throwing money away on the shiny but shallow prospects of the apps and make a successful investment in your dating future. Free up your time and mental energy so you can focus on the things that really matter. Click below to learn more and see if you're a fit for our Get Dateable circle.

Learn More About Our Community

Stay in the loop

You want to stay informed without getting spammed. We've got great info for you. We would love to send you occasional dating tips and updates about what's going on in the Get Dateable community. Join our email list to stay connected.

Thank you for subscribing!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

About the Assessment

You're someone who wants to know yourself better. Our assessment will show you how well you’re doing with physical self-care, emotional stability, communication, community, passion, confidence, financial fitness, and being a good human.

You'll Have Your Own Personal Dating Coach

You don't want generic advice. You want an experienced coach who will personally guide you along every step of your dating journey. We've got you!

You Want to Be In the Inner Circle

Your Get Dateble membership allows you access to exclusive connections, social events and adventures with Austin's top singles.

Austin, our First Stop

Get Dateable was designed with Austin culture in mind. Plans are in the works to expand into other like-minded metropolitan areas!